AGM 2022

Published in Charity: Official
MINUTES
From the 10th Annual General Meeting of the non-profit Association 'Eco Hvar', held on June 17th 2023 at the 'Splendid Cafe' in Jelsa.

Present: Vivian Grisogono - Eco Hvar President, Debora Bunčuga - Secretary, Dinka Barbić - steering committee member, Marija Bunčuga - steering committee member, Sara Radonić - steering committee member, Nada Kozulić, Ingrid Bujis, Rupert Dawnay, Frank John Dubokovich, Toni Hall, Janet Raabe, Olivier Schweitzer, Wendy Zečić

Apologies for absence: Martin Gannon, Jasenka Splivalo
The meeting was opened by Association President Vivian Grisogono at 17:00.
 
AGENDA
1. Welcome. Number of attendees noted, selection of the Meeting Secretary.
2. Adoption of the Minutes from the 9th AGM.
3. Review of Eco Hvar's activities during 2022.
4. Adoption of the Charity's financial report for 2022.
5. Outline of the Charity's programme for 2023.
6. Any other business.
 
1. WELCOME. Vivian Grisogono welcomed the attendees and confirmed that there was a quorum.
Sara Radonić was elected Meeting Secretary, and Debora Bunčuga was deputed to lead the meeting in Croatian, with Vivian Grisogono translating into English as necessary.
 
2. ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES FROM THE 9TH AGM.
The Minutes, which were published previously on the Eco Hvar website in English and Croatian, were circulated to the attendees.
The Meeting adopted the Minutes from the 9th AGM, nem con.
 
3. REVIEW OF ECO HVAR'S ACTIVITIES IN 2022
Requests for help or advice
As in previous years, throughout 2022 people contacted us with various questions, mostly via email or im Facebook, occasionally by telephone. We respond as quickly as possible, usually within a day or two. General inquiries included some unusual requests, such as whether it was allowed for a hotel guest to light a fire outdoors so his family could eat their favourite breakfast rather than the hotel fare (answer 'no'); how does one get rid of a hornets' nest above one's front door (answer, 'please refer to Ekocijan'). More routine questions focused on the insect suppression programme, rodents and rubbish management.
 
Animals
We received c. 83 inquiries about animals on Hvar and elsewhere in Croatia: 32 about dogs, 40 about cats, 4 about birds, 6 about donkeys, and one about horse riding.
As always, we helped as much as we could, directly or indirectly. In most cases, we passed the inquiries on to the relevant town wardens (komunalni redari) who are responsible for taking care of stray dogs, or who should call in the veterinary inspector from Split in the case of mistreated animals.
Volunteers: we are always pleased to received offers of help from volunteers, and recommend them people who need help the most, such as Jana the donkey rescuer in Dol and Chris and Amanda, tireless carers of street cats and stray dogs in Stari Grad.
 
Help for cats
Abandoned kittens are always a major problem, and we remain truly grateful to all those who have helped to save at least some of them.
The project to place feeding stations for stray cats has progressed slowly: we have placed three, one in Stari Grad and two in Jelsa. It has proved difficult to identify places which tick all the boxes: relatively safe for the cats, not likely to cause a nuisance to people, and accessible for ongoing maintenance.
The cat sterilization programmes financed by local councils have been a great help and we are grateful to the authorities who participate. Hvar Town has gone several stages further in trying to help reduce the problems associated with unwanted cats. Nino Pijanović, Hvar's Chief Administrator, has been instrumental in enabling a generous programme of care: not only free sterilizations with local vet Dr. Mirej, but also free food, free transport to the Bestie Animal Shelter in Kaštel Sućurac. It is an example which we hope other local authorities will follow.
 
Help for dogs
The plight of mistreated hunting dogs is still a major concern, for which we are still trying to find a solution. Too often these dogs are not microchipped or vaccinated, and are kept in totally unsatisfactory conditions, chained up, without adequate water or food, even in the hottest months. The Hunting Association should certainly take responsible action to help improve the situation.
On a happier note, as usual our Association has succeeded in saving several dogs during the year. We do not always publicize our activities, as in certain cases this would risk making the situation worse for dogs with aggressive owners, and could jeopardize the safety of those who have reported them. (We always pass on reports and complaints about mistreatments without disclosing the names of the complainants.)
Our successful collaboration with the Bestie Animal Shelter in Kaštel Sućurac has continued. We are very grateful to be able to send rescued dogs there, secure in the knowledge that they will receive excellent care, socialization and some training to prepare them for the time when they find their forever homes.
On October 29th 2022 we were delighted to welcome a group of pupils from the Jelsa Elementary School to Pitve, together with their teacher Irma Bogdanić Cvrković. The pupils practised their (impressive) English as they learned a little about dogs, their needs and characteristics. Ivica Drinković gave an entertaining demonstration of dog training with his dog Luki, who is beloved by all, after which it was playtime, to the delight of the pupils and the dogs.
Social care
We advised the local authority in Jelsa several times that facilities for disabled wheelchair users in the town are woefully inadequate (non-existent) and the ongoing works provided an opportunity to provide minimal facilities such as wheelchair accessible zebra crossings, a paved path through the park from the disabled parking places and disabled access to the newly renovated public toilet. Despite assurances that these would be done, disappointingly none of it has happened. The nearest public toilets for wheelchair users are in the two supermarkets on the outskirts of the town, Plodine and Tommy.
 
For the environment
Pesticides.
We continue unceasingly to promote initiatives for environmental protection at international, national and local levels. Unfortunately, the use of pesticides is still a major problem on our island, as in the whole of Croatia. The struggle to reduce pesticide use is almost 'Mission Impossible', because of the huge financial interests involved. Biocides and so-called 'plant protection products' are granted authorizations on the basis of unpublished industry-financed studies, while independent published studies showing possible adverse effects are not taken into account.
Biocides are authorized by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) and come under the Ministry of Health (MIZ) in Croatia. 'Plant protection products' are approved by the European Union and the Croatian Ministry of Agriculture. The situation is complicated. For example, Cypermethrin is an insecticidal substance which was approved back in 2006, currently approved until 31/01/2029 (EU Pesticides Database, June 2023) or 31/05/2030 (ECHA, June 2023). Cypermethrin is the active ingredient in some 50 insecticidal products on the ECHA listing, c. 53 on the Croatian Health Ministry list (August 2022), and just 6 approved by the Croatian Ministry of Agriculture Phytosanitary Information System (FIS, June 2023). The EU designates it as a 'candidate for substitution, the ECHA does not. The EU, concerned about the potential harm to bees, placed a strict limitation on Cypermethrin-based products in 2021, allowing its use on condition that it is not used when plants of any kind are in flower (legislation 24/22/2021). Yet over many years Cypermethrin has been used in the DDD insect suppression programme around the whole of Hvar: the environment has been sprayed at least 3 times each summer, usually in Cipex 10, with Microfly used round rubbish bins and the rubbish tip. All when plants are flowering and bees are in action.
Another example is the product Closer, whose active ingredient is Sulfoxaflor. Sulfoxaflor is authorized in the EU until 18/08/2025, but not approved by the ECHA. Closer has been the Ministry of Agriculture's insecticide of choice against orange spiny whitefly (aleurocanthus spiniferus). The Ministry even ordered compulsory use of Closer in a garden on a private property on Hvar in September 2021. But in April 2022 the European Commssion restricted the use of Sulfoxaflor to indoors in permanent greenhouses only because of its high risk to pollinators, especially bees.
 
These are just two examples of the harm being done because of the practice of authorizing potentially dangerous pesticides without full and proper investigation of the risks. Occasionally substances are banned, but the bans are slow to come into force, and are anyway ineffective, because pesticide users are not properly educated as to the dangers of the substances they use. For instance, farmers on Hvar are still using the herbicide Roundup / Cidokor, which was banned in the EU way back in 2016. So it's not surprising that there are fewer and fewer bees and other useful insects on Hvar. Every year there is a tragic reduction of biodiversity on the island.
 
In 2022 Association President Vivian Grisogono again sent a hair sample (at her own expense) for pesticide analysis in the Kudzu laboratory in France. The results showed the presence of 6 pesticides: 4,4-DDE, an organophosphate, metabolite of DDT; Allethrin, and Permethrin, synthetic pyrethroid insecticides; Fipronil sulfone, a primary metabolite of the pyrazole insecticide Fipronil; Acetamiprid, a neonicotinoid insecticide; and Azoxystrobin, a strobilurin fungicide. All of these substances have potentially highly dangerous effects on human health.
Ecological workshop.
 
In cooperation with LAG-Škoji we helped to organize a workshop in Jelsa under the title of 'Does Nature Know Better?' Andrea Vugrinović, an expert consultant on organic and biodynamic agriculture, gave a powerful explanation of the modern farming methods which can preserve the health of farmers and citizens, especially children, at the same time saving biodiversity and also reaching the highest levels in the market for produce, with good effects for tourism thrown in. The lecture (in Croatian) is on our Eco Hvar Youtube channel in four parts.
 
See the articles on our website for more information about the pesticides listed:
Many more articles detailing the problems of pesticides are found on our website under the category 'Poisons beware'
 
Eco Hvar in the media. As in previous years, in 2022 Eco Hvar's work was highlighted in print, especially in the widely read regional newspaper Slobodna Dalmacija, thanks to the continuing tireless support of journalist Mirko Crnčević. His exemplary professional work and his understanding of the importance of our aims have definitely increased awareness in a wide-ranging public of the issues of concern regarding animal welfare and environmental protection.
In Slobodna Dalmacija: „Bolje gnoj nego požar!” (07.04.2022.); „Na Hvaru pred sezonu napuštaju štenad, truju mačke...”(23.05.2022); „Na Hvaru će odbaćene plastike proizvoditi atraktivan nakit!” (31.05.2022.); „'Zatrovano zemlište' ili kako varkom p(r)otjerati nepozvane iz vinograda” (02.06.2022.) „Ruglo na Škoju” (29.06.2022.); „'Jelsa ide naprijed, ali su nam nužni čisti spremnici za otpad i oprano mjesto' - Dan Općine” (17.08.2022.); „Vinogradari, dobri primjeri su u Burgundiji” (18.10.2022.); „Bračni par iz Australije zatvorio je poslovnu priču u domovini i u srcu Dalmacije otvorio novu stranicu: ‘Prije četiri godine došli smo nakratko, a onda nas je zavela ljepota‘” (30.10.2022.). In the magazibe 'Dobra kob': „Alarm s otoka. Opasnost prijeti gregulji i kaukulu” (veljača 2022.); „Hvar: želite udomiti psa, javite nam se!” (travanj 2022.); „Uroci „bježe” od rute“ (lipanj 2022.)
 
Facebook. On our Facebook page we continued to post warnings regarding the annual insecticide spraying programme and the hunting season, as well as items of interest, in keeping with our aims.
Website www.eco-hvar.com. We continued to update the information about the adverse effects of pesticides and their approval status, alongside articles about the beauty of our island.
The Meeting accepted the Review of Activities in 2022 nem con.
 
4. FINANCIAL REPORT FOR 2022.
The Association's income during 2022 amounted to 17.053,00 kn, and the outgoings totalled 13.209,00 kn. On 01.01.2022 the account stood at 5.509,00 kn. carried over from the previous year, while on 31.12.2022 it was 9.449,00kn.
The Association's main expenditure is on animal care, accountant's fees and bank expenses. Donations are the Association's sole source of income.
The Financial Report for 2022 was accepted nem. con.
 
5. PROPOSED PROGRAMME FOR 2023.
Our aims remain the same and we plan our programme accordingly.
 
i. Environmental protection and reduction of pesticide use.
We will organize further workshops and lectures, especially with Andrea Vugrinović, who has proved a popular, enthusiastic and compelling lecturer. We will continue to lobby against pesticide use, to raise awareness of the dangers inherent in pesticide use and to promote environmentally friendly methods and products to farmers and sellers.
 
At the end of September 2023 the Research and Development Centre of the 'Island Anatomy' Association (Udruga Anatomija otoka) will be holding its 11th symposium. The subject will be 'Island at the table: Mediterranean food between global processes and island know-how'. The co-organizers of the symposium are from the Zagreb Ethnology and Folklore Institute, with whom Eco Hvar's Secretary Debora Bunčuga had a meeting in May. They are interested in collaborating with our Association and their representative Mrs. Marina Blagaić Bergman will contact us in July to discuss details of the cooperation, focussing especially on our battle against pesticide use. Of course our Association will support the project and cooperate in any way we can.
 
ii. We will organize testing of a certain number of residents for pesticides, with the aim of an eventual comparison with the incidence of illness on the island.
 
iii. Activities for animals
We will continue to develop our pšroject to establish feeding stations for cats in various places, with the help of volunteers who will maintain them.
In the longer term we still hope we might be able to establish a holding station for street cats on the island, under the management of the Beštie Animal Shelter in Kaštela.
We will of course continue our successful collaboration with the Beštie Shelter, as well as our support for individuals who are helping animals on the island.
 
iv. We will continue to support initiatives for eco-tourism on the island.
 
v. We will continue to lobby for adequate conditions for wheelchair users in Jelsa and elsewhere.
 
vi. We will continue to cooperate with like-minded international organizations and national organizations which are working on local and countrywide levels.
The Meeting accepted the Proposed Programme for 2023 nem con.
 
6. ANY OTHER BUSINESS
There was a general discussion on the issues raised in the course of the meeting.
Marija Bunčuga reported that pesticide users were now strictly limited by new regulations: for instance, professional users can only buy a certain quantity of dangerous substances according to the size of their registered fields, and their purchases are recorded. This is certainly a step forward, although, as some attendees commented, it did not stop the problem of purchases from outside Croatia, notably from Bosnia and Hercegovina.
Dinka Barbić reported that some of her guests described seeing many more street cats on Korčula than on Hvar. This led to a discussion as to whether this is due to the sterilization programme working more effectively on Hvar.
Toni Hall commented that castration of male cats, which is currently not funded by the Jelsa Council, is an important part of controlling cat populations. Toni also introduced the subject of re-wilding the island, which led to comments about how difficult it is to control existing populations of wild boar, which cause significant damage to crops every year.
Rupert Dawnay suggested that further education of pesticide users was needed: more specialists should be invited to give lectures and workshops to local farmers and gardeners to demonstrate the alternatives to chemical pesticides. The suggestion met with wholehearted approval from the attendees.
 
The meeting officially closed at 18:30.
 
 
                     Sara Radonić,                                                         Vivian Grisogono, 
                     Meeting Secretary                                                  Association President
More in this category: « AGM 2023. AGM 2021 »
You are here: Home Charity: Official AGM 2022

Eco Environment News feeds

  • The Saudi delegation said it ‘will not accept any text that targets any specific sectors, including fossil fuels’

    My colleague Patrick Greenfield is following the plenary where countries give their formal response to the draft text.

    Cop29 president Mukhtar Babayev gets the plenary started. He asks countries to give their thoughts on the latest iterations of text to inform future versions. He says that with collective effort, he believes that the summit can be finished by 6pm tomorrow.

    Continue reading...

  • All of a sudden I heard this loud noise at the back of my house. The window was smashed in what was supposed to be our secure room. This is Roseman’s story

    Location Union Island, the Caribbean

    Disaster Hurricane Beryl

    Roseman Adams, a nature conservation officer and part of the island’s disaster preparedness committee, was at home on Union Island when Hurricane Beryl hiton 2 July. It was the earliest-formingcategory 5 hurricane on record, demolishing almost all of the buildings on the island of 2,500 people. The climate crisis is making hurricanes ever more intense and destructive.

    Continue reading...

  • Steve Reed says he may not agree on inheritance tax changes but government will listen to rural Britain

    The UK environment secretary has promised to reform the food system to ensure farmers are paid fairly for the food they produce, after many filled the streets of Westminster to campaign against inheritance tax changes.

    Speaking at the Country Land and Business Association (CLA) conference, Steve Reed said: “I heard the anguish of the countryside on the streets of London earlier this week. We may not agree over the inheritance tax changes, but this government is determined to listen to rural Britain and end its long decline.”

    Continue reading...

  • On Qikiqtaruk, off Canada, researchers at the frontier of climate change are seeing its rich ecology slide into the sea as the melting permafrost leaves little behind

    Last summer, the western Arctic was uncomfortably hot. Smoke from Canada’s wildfires hung thick in the air, and swarms of mosquitoes searched for exposed skin. It was a maddening combination that left researchers on Qikiqtaruk, an island off the north coast of the Yukon, desperate for relief.

    And so on a late July afternoon, a team of Canadian scientists dived into the Beaufort Sea, bobbing and splashing in a sheltered bay for nearly two hours. Later, as they lay sprawled on a beach, huge chunks of the island they were studying slid into the ocean.

    Continue reading...

  • Exclusive: Trail would help region with few areas where people can walk in countryside, report says

    A new trail along the east coast of England should be created, a Tory thinktank has said, because farmland is preventing those who live there from having access to nature.

    A report from Onward has found that in most rural areas, people enjoy extensive rights-of-way networks. But across the east of England, there are many areas where people have barely anywhere they are allowed to walk in the countryside. This, the report says, is because of large areas of high-grade farmland in that area, but also because Lincolnshire has the largest backlog for recognition of historical but unrecorded rights of way, with more than 450 outstanding applications.

    Continue reading...

  • Peace Brigades International calling for new act to force companies with links to UK to do due diligence

    Human rights defenders have faced brutal reprisals for standing up to extractive industries with links to UK companies or investors, according to a report calling for a law obliging firms to do human rights and environmental due diligence.

    Peace Brigades International (PBI) UK says a corporate accountability law requiring businesses to do due diligence on their operations, investments and supply chains could have prevented past environmental devastation and attacks.

    Continue reading...

  • ‘While it was dark, I climbed up and put remote control cameras in the tree. I’d never have got the shot if I’d been up there. An orangutan always knows you’re there’

    I was following orangutans in Borneo with my wife, Cheryl Knott, a primatologist who has spent 30 years working in Gunung Palung national park, in the Indonesian part of Borneo. I am a biologist by background, and did my PhD research in rainforest ecology in Borneo, before I went into photography and film-making. I saw so much destruction in the rainforest back in the 90s, and it dawned on me that I could publish scientific articles that maybe 10 people would read – or an article in National Geographic that 10 million people would see.

    I was getting increasingly serious about my photography while working on my PhD when I got funding from the National Geographic Society for field research. Through that connection, I was able to show them my pictures and eventually I published an article in the magazine about my work, which in turn meant I was able to get an assignment to document Cheryl’s orangutan PhD.

    Continue reading...

  • Interviews and analysis of court documents show how the world’s most prestigious consulting firm quietly helps fuel the climate crisis

    Two giant, mirrored walls are set to rise out of the sands of the Arabian desert. They will run parallel for more than 100 miles from the coast of the Red Sea through arid valleys and craggy mountains. Between them, a futuristic city which has no need for cars or roads will be powered completely by renewable energy.

    This engineering marvel, its creators say, will usher in “a revolution in civilization”. It’s the jewel in the crown of a $500bn Saudi government project known as Neom, turning a vast scrubland into a techno-utopia and world-class tourist and sporting destination. Perhaps a harbinger for the end of oil, it will supposedly put the powerful petrostate at the forefront of the energy transition. For American consulting giant McKinsey & Company, its advising on this project appears to be making good on the firm’s green promises.

    Continue reading...

  • A recent strike narrowly missed slave trade archives in Barbados, and experts warn more and worse is to come as global heating intensifies storms

    When the Barbados National Archives, home to one of the world’s most significant collections of documents from the transatlantic slave trade, reported in June that it had been struck by lightning, it received widespread sympathy and offers of support locally and internationally.

    A section of the 60-year-old building, Block D, located on the grounds of the “Lazaretto” (the island’s former colony for people with leprosy), caught fire, and sustained serious damage. Official documents including hospital and school records were lost. “It was not just paper that was in the building, but documents that have stories about our families and ancestors,” says the chief archivist, Ingrid Thompson.

    Continue reading...

  • Unlocking secrets of how the algae survive could help extend growing seasons for crop plants at high latitudes

    Plants left for too long in the dark usually turn sickly yellow and die, but scientists were astonished to discover tiny microalgae in the Arctic Ocean down to 50 metres deep can perform photosynthesis in near darkness.

    The microalgae were at 88-degrees north and started photosynthesising in late March, only a few days after the long winter polar night came to an end at this latitude. The sun was barely poking up above the horizon and the sea was still covered in snow and ice, barely allowing any light to pass through. Typical light conditions outside on a clear day in Europe are more than 37,000-50,000 times the amount of light required by these Arctic microalgae.

    Continue reading...

Eco Health News feeds

Eco Nature News feeds

  • A Conservation International scientist shares what can be done to prevent an ‘outright alarming’ future for whale sharks.

  • A new Conservation International study measures the cooling effects of forests against extreme heat — with eye-opening results.

  • EDITOR’S NOTE:Few places on Earth are as evocative — or as imperiled — as the vast grasslands of sub-Saharan Africa. In a new Conservation News series, “Saving the Savanna,” we look at how communities are working to protect these places — and the wildlife within.

    MARA NORTH CONSERVANCY, Kenya — Under a fading sun, Kenya’s Maasai Mara came alive.

    A land cruiser passed through a wide-open savanna, where a pride of lions stirred from a day-long slumber. Steps away, elephants treaded single-file through tall grass, while giraffes peered from a thicket of acacia trees. But just over a ridge was a sight most safari-goers might not expect — dozens of herders guiding cattle into an enclosure for the night. The herders were swathed in vibrant red blankets carrying long wooden staffs, their beaded jewelry jingling softly.

    Maasai Mara is the northern reach of a massive, connected ecosystem beginning in neighboring Tanzania’s world-famous Serengeti. Unlike most parks, typically managed by local or national governments, these lands are protected under a wildlife conservancy — a unique type of protected area managed directly by the Indigenous People who own the land.

    Conservancies allow the people that live near national parks or reserves to combine their properties into large, protected areas for wildlife. These landowners can then earn income by leasing that land for safaris, lodges and other tourism activities. Communities in Maasai Mara have created 24 conservancies, protecting a total of 180,000 hectares (450,000 acres) — effectively doubling the total area of habitat for wildlife in the region, beyond the boundaries of nearby Maasai Mara National Reserve.

    “It's significant income for families that have few other economic opportunities — around US$ 350 a month on average for a family. In Kenya, that's the equivalent of a graduate salary coming out of university,” said Elijah Toirai, Conservation International’s community engagement lead in Africa.

    © Jon McCormack

    Lions tussle in the tall grass of Mara North Conservancy.

    But elsewhere in Africa, the conservancy model has remained far out of reach.

    “Conservancies have the potential to lift pastoral communities out of poverty in many African landscapes. But starting a conservancy requires significant funding — money they simply don't have,” said Bjorn Stauch, senior vice president of Conservation International’s nature finance division.

    Upfront costs can include mapping out land boundaries, removing fences that prevent the movement of wildlife, eradicating invasive species that crowd out native grasses, creating firebreaks to prevent runaway wildfires, as well building infrastructure like roads and drainage ditches that are essential for successful safaris. Once established, conservancies need to develop management plans that guide their specified land use for the future.

    Conservation International wanted to find a way for local communities to start conservancies and strengthen existing ones. Over the next three years, the organization aims to invest millions of dollars in new and emerging conservancies across Southern and East Africa. The funds will be provided as loans, which the conservancies will repay through tourism leases. This financing will jumpstart new conservancies and reinforce those already in place. The approach builds on an initial model that has proven highly effective and popular with local communities.

    “We’re always looking for creative new ways to pay for conservation efforts that last,” Stauch said. “This is really a durable financing mechanism that puts money directly in the pockets of those who live closest to nature — giving them a leg up. And it’s been proven to work in the direst circumstances imaginable.”

    © Will McCarry

    Elijah Toirai explains current conservancy boundaries and potential areas for expansion.

    Creativity from crisis

    In 2020, the entire conservancy model almost collapsed overnight.

    “No one thought that the world could stop in 24 hours,” said Kelvin Alie, senior vice president and acting Africa lead for Conservation International. “But then came the pandemic, and suddenly Kenya is shutting its doors on March 23, 2020. And in the Mara, this steady and very well-rounded model based on safari tourism came to a screeching halt.”

    Tourism operators, who generate the income to pay landowners' leases, found themselves without revenue. Communities faced a difficult choice: replace the lost income by fencing off their lands for grazing, converting it to agriculture, or selling to developers — each of which would have had drastic consequences for the Maasai Mara’s people and wildlife.

    © Will Turner

    A black-backed jackal hunts for prey.

    “But then the nature finance team at Conservation International — these crazy guys — came up with a wild idea,” Alie said. “In just six months they put this entirely new funding model together: loaning money at an affordable rate to the conservancies so that they can continue to pay staff and wildlife rangers.”

    Conservation International and the Maasai Mara Wildlife Conservancies Association launched the African Conservancies Fund — a rescue package to offset lost revenues for approximately 3,000 people in the area who rely on tourism income. Between December 2020 and December 2022, the fund provided more than US$ 2 million in affordable loans to four conservancies managing 70,000 hectares (170,000 acres).

    The loans enabled families in the Maasai Mara to continue receiving income from their lands to pay for health care, home repairs, school fees and more. And because tourism revenues — not government funding — support wildlife protection in conservancies, this replacement funding ensured wildlife patrols continued normally, with rangers working full time.

    Born out of this emergency, we discovered a new way to do conservation.

    Elijah Toirai

    “The catastrophe of COVID-19 was total for us,” said Benard Leperes, a landowner with Mara North Conservancy and a conservation expert at Maasai Mara Wildlife Conservancies Association. “Without Conservation International and the fund, this landscape would have not been secured; the conservancies would have disintegrated as people were forced to sell their land to convert it to agriculture.”

    But it was communities themselves that proved the model might be replicable after the pandemic ended.

    “The conservancies had until 2023 before the first payment was due,” Toirai said. “But as soon as tourism resumed in mid-2021, the communities started paying back the loans. Today, the loans are being repaid way ahead of schedule.”

    “Born out of this emergency, we discovered a new way to do conservation.”

    A new era for conservation

    The high plateaus overlooking the Maasai Mara are home to the very last giant pangolins in Kenya.

    These mammals, armored with distinctive interlocking scales, are highly endangered because of illegal wildlife trade. In Kenya, threats from poaching, deforestation and electric fences meant to deter elephants from crops have caused the species to nearly disappear. Today, scientists believe there could be as few as 30 giant pangolins left in Kenya.

    Conservancies could be crucial to bringing them back. Conservation International has identified opportunities to provide transformative funding for conservancies in this area — a sprawling grassland northwest of Maasai Mara that is the very last pangolin stronghold in the country. The fund will help communities better protect an existing 10,000-hectare (25,000-acre) conservancy and bring an additional 5,000 hectares under protection. It provides a safety net, ensuring a steady income for the communities as the work of expanding the conservancy begins. With a stable income, communities can start work to restore the savanna and remove electric fences that have killed pangolins. And as wildlife move back into the ecosystem, the grasslands will begin to recover.

    In addition to expanding conservancies around Maasai Mara, Conservation International has identified other critical ecosystems where community conservancies can help lift people out poverty, while providing new habitats for wildlife. Conservation International has ambitious plans to restore a critical and highly degraded savanna between Amboseli and Tsavo National Parks in southern Kenya, as well as a swath of savanna outside Kruger National Park in South Africa.

    © Emily Nyrop

    A lone acacia tree in a sea of grass.

    Elephants, fire, Maasai and cattle

    Many of the new and emerging community conservancies have been carefully chosen as key wildlife corridors that would be threatened by overgrazing livestock.

    When the first Maasai Mara conservancies were established in 2009, cattle grazing was prohibited within their boundaries. When poorly managed, cattle can wear grasses down to their roots, triggering topsoil erosion and the loss of nutrients, microbes and biodiversity vital for soil health. It was also believed that tourists would be put off by the sight of livestock mingling with wildlife.

    © Emily Nyrop

    Cattle are closely monitored in the Maasai Mara to prevent overgrazing.

    However, over the years, landowners objected, lamenting the loss of cultural ties to cattle and herding. “That was when we changed tactics,” said Raphael Kereto, the grazing manager for Mara North Conservancy.

    Beginning in 2018, Mara North and other conservancies in the region started adopting livestock grazing practices to restore the savanna. Landowners agreed to periodically move livestock between different pastures, allowing grazed lands to recover and regrow,  mimicking the traditional methods pastoralists have used on these lands for hundreds, if not thousands, of years.

    “Initially, there was a worry that maybe herbivores and other wildlife will run away from cattle,” said Kereto. “But we have seen the exact opposite — the wildlife all follow where cattle are grazing. This is because we have a lot of grass, and all the animals follow where there is a lot of grass. We even saw a cheetah with a cub that spent all her time rotating with wildlife.”

    “It's amazing — when we move cattle, the cheetah comes with it.”

    The loans issued by the fund — now called the African Conservancies Facility — will enhance rotational grazing systems, which are practiced differently in each conservancy, by incorporating best practices and lessons from the organization’s Herding for Health program in southern Africa.

    © Will Turner

    An elephant herd stares down a pack of hyenas.

    For landowners like Dickson Kaelo, who was among the pioneers to propose the conservancy model in Kenya, the return of cattle to the ecosystem has restored a natural order.

    “I always wanted to understand how it was that there was so much more wildlife in the conservancies than in Maasai Mara National Reserve,” said Kaelo, who heads the Kenya Wildlife Conservancy Association, based in Nairobi.

    “I went to the communities and asked them this question. They told me savannas were created by elephants, fire and Maasai and cattle, and excluding any one of those is not good for the health of the system. So, I believe in the conservancies — I know that every single month, people go to the bank and they have some money, they haven't lost their culture because they still are cattle keepers, and the land is much healthier, with more grass, more wildlife, and the trees have not been cut.

    “For me, it’s something really beautiful.”


    Further reading:

    Will McCarry is the content director at Conservation International. Want to read more stories like this? Sign up for email updates. Also, please consider supporting our critical work.

  • Conservation International is helping recover a savanna habitat nearly twice the size of Manhattan.

  • “Nature is resilient — when given the chance.” A Conservation International study shows where trees can grow back on their own — and fight climate change.

  • "Before, we were working blind": A new Conservation International study gives scientists an unprecedented view into a remote tropical forest.

  • Conservation International is launching a historic conservation partnership to plant 1 billion trees and protect 1 million hectares across India, Bhutan, Bangladesh and Nepal.

  • More than one in three of the world’s tree species are at risk of extinction, according to the first Global Tree Assessment, published today.

  • Ocean protections are lagging dangerously. Here’s what it’s going to take to meet global goals, according to a Conservation International marine scientist.

  • Years of civil war left Mozambique’s national parks in ruins. But in one park, a decade of conservation has brought the savanna roaring back to life. Now, Conservation International and Peace Parks Foundation are replicating this success on a massive scale.